I have had good results with both the Remington and the Barnes Vor-Tx. Both deer shot at about 50 yards through the boiler room, but neither made it out of the small field.
I've shot two apiece with Barnes VorTx 110gr black tip and Hornady Black 110 gr. vmax.
The deer shot with the Vmax crumpled where they stood. Massive internal damage but no exit wound.
The deer shot with the Barnes, one crumpled in place the other made two uncoordinated bounds into a Pete Rose slide.
I'm happy with either but the Barnes is my primary. Just picked up a couple more boxes.
Shots above ranged from almost straight down out to 60-70 yards. Can't really shoot more than about 80 yards from most of my stands. Thick creek bottoms.