By Request, The story of how I broke my back in a tree stand accident

RR

....glutton for punishment.....
Staff member
Charter Life Member
Benefactor
Sponsor
Multi-Factor Enabled
Joined
Dec 16, 2016
Messages
8,410
Location
Alamance County, NC
Rating - 100%
90   0   0
Tomorrow will be the 10 year anniversary of my accident. Given that bow season is here, someone asked that I repost this story for everyone. Some of you may have read it 10 years ago at CSF when originally posted or one of the reposts since. But for those who haven't heard or read this before, enjoy :) ....

On Saturday, Sept 22nd, 2007, I went into work for about 8 hours and then headed for the woods to bow hunt. I was tired and PO'd from work and really needed the relaxation of a nice evening hunt. We had our 3 year accreditation visit scheduled for the following Monday and we'd all been putting in extra hours to prepare. I had worked about 60 hours that week and really needed the break.

I picked up my father in law and headed to the farm. He headed to the backside of the farm. I made the decision to go to my favorite stand where I'd seen four the previous Saturday. This is a wooden built stand that I've hunted for more than 10 years and have taken 15-16 deer from in that time. It has never failed to account for at least one deer in a season.

I got to the stand at about 4:30PM and tied my bow off and started climbing. As I reached the top rung of the ladder, I grabbed for a limb that I've used a thousand times to haul myself into my seat. The limb broke sending all 230lbs of me tumbling backward approximately 18ft to the ground below. I landed on my back on my pack and some wood. I was immediately out. I don't know for how long, but I know I was unconscious for a bit.

I came to and tried to ge
t up. It was a definite no go. I could move my arms and my legs. My toes and fingers all worked, but I didn't have the strength to stand and even attempting to was excruciating. I suspected then that I'd broken my back. I tried yelling for help, but I didn't have the wind to yell very loud and my father in law was some distance away by that point. I think I passed out again somewhere along there.

I remember fumbling my cell phone out of it's case, but I don't remember who I called. Turns out I called my mother in law first who couldn't understand what I was saying and assumed it was an obscene phone call (Lots of gasping/heavy breathing, No caller ID). I called my wife next and finally got her to understand what had happened and that I was seriously injured. She was at work about 20 mins from where we hunt. She headed toward me while trying to get my father in law on his cell phone. At this point I had passed out again.

I remember hearing my father in law coming through the woods to me that woke me up. He was on the phone with my wife and was directing her how to find us. Unfortunately he didn't believe that my back was broken and tried to get me to my feet again, which of course didn't work too well. Finally I think it sunk in how bad I was hurt and he sat down with me and talked to me, trying to keep me alert. I was in and out again.

My wife arrived and they finally got 911 on the way. When the dispatcher asked her the cause of the accident she replied, "Stupidity." Yes, somewhere in the archives of Orange Co. 911 there exists that
recording. I have a such a loving wife. They were trying to figure out how the EMT's were gonna get me out of the woods, I ain't the easiest package to haul around and I was about 100 yds into some pretty thick woods from the cornfield which was as far as the ambulance could go. We were about a mile off the paved road. As soon as she hung up the phone I remember hearing sirens in the distance. I think I passed out again. My wife headed out to the paved road to lead the EMS crew into where I was while my father in law stayed with me to keep me conscious. I remember him telling me a story about a mutual friend of ours doing this same thing 20 years ago and having to crawl 3 miles back to his house. At least I wouldn’t be crawling.

The EMT crew finally arrived and checked me over. They cut my shirt away and found a deformity around L-1. My hips hurt and my left hand was starting to turn purple. I was having trouble breathing. They put a cervical collar on me and strapped me to a back board and discussed briefly how they would haul my rather large carriage out of the woods to the ambulance. I heard the word helicopter mentioned for the first time somewhere around here. They discussed using the John Deere Gator they had along to cart me out. They actually got it stuck trying to get it in to me so that was thankfully out. The female EMT was driving it into the woods and all I can hear is this engine revving coming right toward me. I'm laying there thinking, "This ***** is gonna run me over" and it's not like I can get up and move. Finally I hear the "Wham" of the gator getting stuck between two trees. They had to cut one of them down later to get it out. What can I say, the EMT's had new toys to play with....

The three men and one woman of the EMS crew lifted me and carried me about 50 yds before they had to stop for a break. You know those backboards flex right? Yeah that part kinda sucked. This was repeated a couple more times before we got back to the cornfield. The trouble was instead of following the well used foot trail that leads from where I park my truck to that stand they chose to head through the densest damn cedar thicket on that property. I was pissed...A week later when I finally got home and showered for the first time I had cedar nettles washed out of my hair.

Once I was out in the open they did a more thorough exam and became concerned about my breathing. They were convinced that my right lung was partially collapsed. They stuck a needle in my chest to relieve the pressure. They found out then my lung wasn’t collapsed. The needle in the chest thing really sucked.

At this point they find out that both of UNC’s helo’s are occupied at the moment but they can get one in from Duke and take me to UNC. It was a go. 5 minutes later the helo was touching down and everyone was covered in dirt from the cornfield. They got me on the helo and while strapping me down, ripped the needle out of my chest. It hurt, but it immediately felt better once it was out of there too. Within minutes they were unloading me on the roof of UNC Hospitals in Chapel Hill. I remember asking for water and being told they couldn’t give me anything because I’d likely be in surgery soon.

They got me into the ER and I was in and out of consciousness through most of it. I remember them catheterizing me. I wish I didn’t. I remember meeting my Neurosurgeon for the first time. He said that they knew my back was broken, but that I still had use of all extremities and while I may need surgery I should recover without loss of function. He said they would do Xrays soon to confirm and then make a plan. I again asked for water and he said unfortunately no since I may be a candidate for emergency surgery.

Several hours, two brutal sets of xrays, an MRI from hell and CT scan later they determine that I have a severe burst fracture of L-1. My hips and ribs are unbroken as is my left hand.

About that MRI...My shoulders barely fit into the machine....actually barely is stretching it....my shoulders didn't fit the machine...so every time the table moved back and forth in the scanner, my shoulders drug along the sides. Imagine how that repeated sretching and compression felt on that shattered vertebra...

At this point it's about 2 AM. Since I’m not losing any strength in my lower body and the surgery itself carries a level of risk of paralysis, they decide to postpone 'til the next day when the doctors are fresher. I finally got some water. The doctor described for me for the first time the surgery they would do. 8 titanium screws into the vertebra that’s broken plus the two above and one below. 2 titanium rods run through those screws plus a horizontal stabilizing bar connecting them. They will take my own bone fragments along with cadaver bone (I see dead people...) and seed the area around it to allow bone growth to fuse all this in place.

They move me into a room sometime that night along with a fellow who’s just had his second brain surgery and isn’t quite himself. I was pretty looped out on strong painkillers from here forward so the next couple of days are a blur. I remember them bumping my surgery from Sunday to Monday because more emergent cases came first. Since I still had use of my legs I was less severe than some of those who were coming in. Starting Monday morning early I started having muscle spasms in my back. My legs were being drawn straight up into my body by these spasms. I felt like I was being torn in half every time one came on. They came about every half hour.
 
Part 2.....

They took me down for one more set of xrays before surgery. Every time they do this they have to transfer me onto a back board and then a stretcher. Every time they do this I nearly pass out from the pain and the spasms that are triggered by the movement. Finally they prescribe a muscle relaxant which stops the spasms and pretty much knocks me out.

They came to get me for surgery sometime after lunch on Monday. I barely remember them rolling me out of the room. I don’t remember getting to the OR or counting backward or any of that. I do remember coming out of surgery in a world of pain with a morphine button in my hand. That button became my best friend for the next 24 hours.

I was in and out over the next couple of days. When I was with it enough my wife filled me in on a few details the surgeon shared with her post surgery. There was a lot of muscle damage done by the bone fragments. There was also a lot of muscle for them to cut through due to my size. Because of the positioning of the break and the density of my bones they weren’t able to drill the 8th screw in so I only have 7. One of the nurses informed the doctor as they were closing the wound that the stabilizing bar showed markers for spore contamination. She should have disclosed this an hour and a half earlier, but did not. This lengthened the surgery time somewhat as the surgeon had to call the CDC in Atlanta for advice. He may have had to undo everything he’d just spent five hours doing. They advised to close the wound and use heavier than normal antibiotic protocols to prevent infection. Later on a check of records determined that the bolt in question had been in the autoclave long enough that spore infection was impossible. The markers themselves were faulty.

I spent several days and nights in the room with the fellow who’d had brain surgery. That was an unceasing adventure. He was deaf so he was loud and everyone who talked to him was loud (as if that would make him hear them). Everyone who walked past my bed to his somehow felt the need to bump into it. I found myself screaming “Hello, Back Surgery!” a couple times. After several sleepless nights (I got so tired of hearing him yell, “Do you have any idea who I am?”) they moved me to a private room on the other end of the floor.

I believe it was the day after my surgery that I got a visit from two Wildlife Officers following up on my accident. They had spoken to my father in law and had been to the site of the accident. They saw the branch that gave way and the distance I fell. Their assessment was that I was lucky to be alive much less walking. They took a full report and wished me the best of luck in recovery.

By the second day after surgery they had me fitted for a turtleshell brace and walking around the hallways in the hospital. It was painful at first but got easier. In the course of a week I think I was cath'd 4 or 5 times. I felt so violated. There's this funky side effect of heavy use of painkillers where your bladder spasms shut. Yeah that part sucked too.

By Thursday and Friday they started talking discharge. They would have let me go home Friday night, but I was tired from walking and really just wanted to sleep. They postponed my discharge for Saturday. By 2:00PM Saturday I was headed home. I really was cursing the Governor for his repeated raidings of the highway trust fund to balance the state budget all the way home. I felt every pothole. The grand total of my hospital bills came to just north of $123,000.00. Luckily I have good health insurance.

I spent 5 weeks recovering at home before going back to work part time. I was back at work full time at 6 weeks and went back hunting 6 weeks to the day from the accident. I hunted every available opportunity the rest of that season, even in a back brace. I think that level of activity was what helped progress my recovery. Usually they follow spinal fusion patients for a year post-op. I was discharged by my surgeon 4 months after surgery with no restrictions to my activities.


I spent the first 5 years after surgery in a fairly constant state of pain. It would ebb and flow and I got used to being pretty miserable. In 2012 I went Paleo and removed all grains and added sugars from my diet. As part of that shift I learned that I'm gluten intolerant and the inflammation caused by wheat, plus the injury, was what was causing the chronic pain. I've been off all painkillers since. I take a flexeril once in a blue moon when I overdo things, but that is rare these days.

This story could have ended very differently. I could have easily died from that fall. People do so every year. Please use good judgement when hunting. Avoid home built stands and use a fall arrest system, preferably with a lifeline/prussic knot system that will keep you tethered the whole time your feet are off the ground.

Stay safe out there folks......
 
Thanks for sharing this with our CFF members Tom. I have shared this story also with a number of others to help convey a message of safety and what can happen if you are not taking all necessary precautions while climbing to higher levels.

If it only helps one person the time you've taken in posting this was worth it.
 
We're glad to still have you with us and in one piece.
 
Dang it Bobby. It is dangerous. I've hauled many out of the woods and picked up several on the helicopter. And even a low F/X like that can give you paralysis.

Glad you made it out ok!
 
I remember vaguely reading about that in a distant forum and thinking how bad that must have sucked. It's no different hearing it now. I think it's interesting how you found out about the gluten and it resolved the inflammation/pain.
 
When I was in the hospital with my back surgery, after they removed my catheter, I couldn't pee if I wasn't standing up. Needed gravity to assist where my pain medicated muscles couldn't "push". Needless to say, when I was having to get up every 45 minutes to pee, I had them dial back the IV saline drip. The funny thing was, I had to pee SO BAD the first 30 minutes after the cath removal but I couldn't push it laying down. Three nurses didn't believe I knew I had to pee. One of them even got an ultrasound machine and checked my bladder with it. Guess what? IT WAS FULL. They realized they had to help me get up then...sorry, not sorry nursin' lady, you gotta work today. I peed over a liter of fluid; they had to empty the bedside urinal and bring it back.
 
I watched my dad repair a stand today. He climbed the ladder stick but decided to use a dead pine branch to leverage himself to adjust the stand. Guess what happened to that limb? Luckily, he had one hand on another limb and his other hand on the stand. He was over 20' up a tree and the harness was another three or four feet above him.

He's one lucky dog.

Thanks for sharing that story.
 
I've seen it happen several times, and more than once the ending wasn't nearly as nice as yours. You have to be careful. There are no do - overs in the real world. If you have young people you're teaching, make sure you teach 'em how to be safe first and foremost.

'preciate you reposting it, RR.
 
When I was in the hospital with my back surgery, after they removed my catheter, I couldn't pee if I wasn't standing up. Needed gravity to assist where my pain medicated muscles couldn't "push". Needless to say, when I was having to get up every 45 minutes to pee, I had them dial back the IV saline drip. The funny thing was, I had to pee SO BAD the first 30 minutes after the cath removal but I couldn't push it laying down. Three nurses didn't believe I knew I had to pee. One of them even got an ultrasound machine and checked my bladder with it. Guess what? IT WAS FULL. They realized they had to help me get up then...sorry, not sorry nursin' lady, you gotta work today. I peed over a liter of fluid; they had to empty the bedside urinal and bring it back.
Standing, laying in bed, sitting on the toilet. None of it worked for me. From the time I fell on Saturday until Friday about mid day I had no voluntary ability to pee. Every day they would pull the Cath out. Later that day I would be so miserable from not being able to go that they would have to out it back in. And yeah the bladder ultrasounds SUUUUCK when you're bladder had been painfully distended for so long and you've been cath'd several times.....

Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
 
...system that will keep you tethered the whole time your feet are off the ground.

This is essential, but is most often ignored by people climbing ladders. If you haven't got it figured out how to climb a ladder while tethered the entyre time, ya really should stop and think about it. Two carbiners and a second tether added to a modern harness will get it done.

I remember when you fell in 2007, Rattling. I've re-read it every time you have posted the story. It might have been you that pointed out that 1 out of every 3 people who use a tree stand will fall. That stat will really make ya take notice!
 
Now maybe some of you people might understand why Homie don't go above the 2nd step on a 6' ladder. If God wanted me up that tree he would have given me climbing claws.
I have used a climbing stand in my younger days, it slipped once, I slid about 2-3 feet and then it stopped. My pants leg was soaked but my brain was clear, I left that SOB where it hung and never went back there again. I have really nice ground blinds that I use today....
 
great reminder to use a harness. The boys and I hung a ladder stand yesterday that one of them will hunt on Saturday morning. While my skinny 85lb 13 year old was up there and we were holding the ladder, he tightened the strap up and it broke....needless to say they both learned that lesson quick that a ladder stand isn't permanent and those straps suck.

Everyone be safe this deer season!
 
I replace ladder stand straps every year.

Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
Well...did you ever figure out who the guy was that kept asking you?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Well...did you ever figure out who the guy was that kept asking you?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Nope. Not at all...... But he was apparently an important fellow...

Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
 
I got lucky. I had screw in steps break loose and throw me out of a tree from about 12' up. Straight to my back on reasonably soft ground. Not fun. Didn't get hurt though. I don't use steps anymore.

I had to put up a ladder stand last week. The worst part is all the work before you get the tether up and attached. I have a climbing harness and lobster claw set that I use as soon as I can get it on the tree. Pretty neat little contraption, I'll try and get some pics. Went a couple days ago and put a tether on the two person stand my daughter and I will use Sat. Added a strap to the tree at the seat so we are not both on the same tether when we get in the stand.

FYI, if you are handy with knots and trust yourself you can make tethers pretty easily. Arborist rope and some prussic cord. For guys with a stand or two, $40 a pop might not be too bad. When you have multiple stands it makes sense to learn what to use and how to make them.
 
I got lucky. I had screw in steps break loose and throw me out of a tree from about 12' up. Straight to my back on reasonably soft ground. Not fun. Didn't get hurt though. I don't use steps anymore.

I had to put up a ladder stand last week. The worst part is all the work before you get the tether up and attached. I have a climbing harness and lobster claw set that I use as soon as I can get it on the tree. Pretty neat little contraption, I'll try and get some pics. Went a couple days ago and put a tether on the two person stand my daughter and I will use Sat. Added a strap to the tree at the seat so we are not both on the same tether when we get in the stand.

FYI, if you are handy with knots and trust yourself you can make tethers pretty easily. Arborist rope and some prussic cord. For guys with a stand or two, $40 a pop might not be too bad. When you have multiple stands it makes sense to learn what to use and how to make them.
One of the few useful things I found during the Gander going out of business sale was a 3 pack of HSS lifelines for just over 25 bucks.

Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
 
Thanks for sharing. We've chatted about this before.

When I was a medic I would average three hunting accidents a year; none of them were closer to a mile from the road, the furthest was about 4.

I hope you sent OCEMS a narrative of your experiences; an AAR is a great learning tool.

So glad you are a function biped now.
 
Took pics of my lobster claw set. Figure 8 on a bite for attaching to the harness. Prussic knot for adjustment. One carabiner to attack to the harness and one on the end of the prussic loop. This is my rig for hanging stands. I can use it as a climbing belt or hook it to the tree and hang from it.



19a24affd9404897d21da3a4300d665e.jpg



64df625a663ba23bc027494dd40d6299.jpg



ef940346c6fff2ad795b906e82a2fa83.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
A guy at work had a friend fall out of a stand last year. He survived but shattered both legs.

The box stand I put up this year is only about 4.5' off the ground instead of 12' that it used to be.

Thanks again for the re-post.
 
I taught hunters ed for a few times and stories like these give me goose pimples. Very glad you recovered at such a quick rate. Your story and others like it are the reason I now religiously use a safety line at all stands and especially with my climber. Glad to hear you doid not give up on . the sport and are a solid testament to tree stand safety.
 
I taught hunters ed for a few times and stories like these give me goose pimples. Very glad you recovered at such a quick rate. Your story and others like it are the reason I now religiously use a safety line at all stands and especially with my climber. Glad to hear you doid not give up on . the sport and are a solid testament to tree stand safety.
I got certified after my accident and taught for a few years. Until we started having kids again.

I would bring my back brace and a harness and say pick one to wear.....

Sent from my Pixel using Tapatalk
 
I've been working in the ER here for 5yrs, we get several every season falling out of stands. I always use a climber, and I wear my vest when I climb up or down. But still have that falling thing in the back of head every time I go up,
I have a Summit that is nice and light, but it's time for new cables.
I also have an old Rivers Edge, weighs a ton, solid steel bars to grip the tree, makes a racket setting it up, but climbs great and is as solid as a rock.
Everyone stay safe in the trees this season, you don't want to see my ugly face in the ER.
 
Thank you for posting again. Good timing with everyone getting their stands set up. I have had close calls and am very thankful nothing bad has happened. I am like several others on here. As I get older, I stay closer to the ground to hunt. Amazing how fast something bad happens
 
Went to the now required hunters safety class a couple of weeks ago as I want to start hunting deer this year. They said the number one cause of injury is falling out of a tree or stand and the importance of using a good, properly fitted harness / fall arrest system.
 
I glad you made a good recovery, many don't. I have only hunted a few times but I just don't like stands. I don't mind heights but just don't trust the stands. I use ground blinds. I might try hunting again this year..... Think a 7.62x54 with a 180gr soft point would be enough for Bambi?? ;)
 
I glad you made a good recovery, many don't. I have only hunted a few times but I just don't like stands. I don't mind heights but just don't trust the stands. I use ground blinds. I might try hunting again this year..... Think a 7.62x54 with a 180gr soft point would be enough for Bambi?? ;)

Plenty enough.....
 
Took pics of my lobster claw set. Figure 8 on a bite for attaching to the harness. Prussic knot for adjustment. One carabiner to attack to the harness and one on the end of the prussic loop. This is my rig for hanging stands. I can use it as a climbing belt or hook it to the tree and hang from it.



19a24affd9404897d21da3a4300d665e.jpg



64df625a663ba23bc027494dd40d6299.jpg



ef940346c6fff2ad795b906e82a2fa83.jpg


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
How a bout a vid on making and using it? I've got a dozen spare carabiners.
 
How a bout a vid on making and using it? I've got a dozen spare carabiners.

I'll see what I can do. You will need static rope for the line. You don't want it to give. Used to have buddy that built high ropes courses and he made it for me.
 
Back
Top Bottom