Against the better judgements and wishes of others, I'm going to pick the scabs off these wounds. The sports analogies for drills vs actual tactical situations didn't work for me. The best analogies I can come up with are in the martial arts. Chuck Norris, Joe Lewis, Bruce Lee, Bigfoot Wallace and others (you can tell my age by these names) ran many "drills," forms, kata, practice, or whatever you want to call it. But if you don't think they would kick your ass in a fight, you never saw them fight.
In "karate," you learn the basics by drilling over and over and over. You then learn forms to put the drills into sequence. You then spar to put all that to practical use. You might then enter competitions to test your skills.
Drills, whether for competition or tactical use, are still drills.
Until someone can tell me how to transition from drills of any sort to the sparring or competition level of martial arts, I'll stick with my competition drills. It's because that's what I do - compete. I don't run around picking fights where someone will be firing back lethal bullets at me. And I have my doubts that pretending someone is firing back will ever prepare you for the real deal.
In the couple years I trained in Tae Kwon Do, it took about 6-8 sparring bouts to get over the hyperventilation feeling of being in a fight. After that, I was confident I could react more favorably, and either create distance or effectively (as effectively as I was capable) counter a bull-rush.
Rob Leatham says at the end of this video, "...because I'm set up to play a game right now. However, I doubt most people would want to get into a gunfight with me!"
In "karate," you learn the basics by drilling over and over and over. You then learn forms to put the drills into sequence. You then spar to put all that to practical use. You might then enter competitions to test your skills.
Drills, whether for competition or tactical use, are still drills.
Until someone can tell me how to transition from drills of any sort to the sparring or competition level of martial arts, I'll stick with my competition drills. It's because that's what I do - compete. I don't run around picking fights where someone will be firing back lethal bullets at me. And I have my doubts that pretending someone is firing back will ever prepare you for the real deal.
In the couple years I trained in Tae Kwon Do, it took about 6-8 sparring bouts to get over the hyperventilation feeling of being in a fight. After that, I was confident I could react more favorably, and either create distance or effectively (as effectively as I was capable) counter a bull-rush.
Rob Leatham says at the end of this video, "...because I'm set up to play a game right now. However, I doubt most people would want to get into a gunfight with me!"