Loading Hornady 140 gr .357 Flex Tip

303hunter

Loves Tommiegirl
Charter Member
Supporting Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2017
Messages
1,988
Location
Fayetteville, NC
Rating - 100%
50   0   0
Has anyone loaded this bullet for a revolver? I saw them for sale at Academy, and they seem like a good deer hunting bullet. Any opinions?
 
Not the flex tip, but I had a good 140 gr. XTP load worked up at one time that my blackhawk and Marlin loved. I can look back through my notes on that if you like. Pretty sure it was an H110 load.
 
Not the flex tip, but I had a good 140 gr. XTP load worked up at one time that my blackhawk and Marlin loved. I can look back through my notes on that if you like. Pretty sure it was an H110 load.
That would be great. I use a lot of H110/W296 for my loads.
 
Found it. Didn't take long.

H110. Looks like I started with 16.9 and worked my way up to 18.4 gr. (check current charts on that as this was several years ago....)
Looks like the sweet spot for group size and consistent velocity was 17.9 gr. That was in a 20" barreled 1894 and a 4 5/8" bbl Blackhawk. Avg velocity was 1319 in the revolver and 1826fps in the lever gun. My notes say one ragged hole at 25 for the revolver and 1.5" at 50 for the lever.
 
Has anyone loaded this bullet for a revolver? I saw them for sale at Academy, and they seem like a good deer hunting bullet. Any opinions?
Problem with the 140 flex tip is that the case has to be trimmed shorter than normal for 357mag, so that the bullet can be seated short enough to fit the max OAL for 357mag.
 
Problem with the 140 flex tip is that the case has to be trimmed shorter than normal for 357mag, so that the bullet can be seated short enough to fit the max OAL for 357mag.

True, sometimes ;)

Those loading in Single shots (Handi rifles, TC etc) don't worry about max COAL with the gummy tip .358's.

For lever or wheelguns, it's an issue.

My bolt action 357 will feed the 140 gum tips in 357mag brass. It will not feed the 200+ gr flextips, so I just use 38 spl brass and pay attention to not compress the powder (too much.)
 
Hodgdons data has the FTX at 14.5 gr max load versus 19.0 for the XTP, so the FTX has to be a substantially longer bullet.
 
Those loading in Single shots (Handi rifles, TC etc) don't worry about max COAL with the gummy tip .358's.
Yes, and I think some revolvers have cylinders long enough to accommodate them. What bugs me is if I get some once-fired 357 Hornady brass, then I have to really pay attention to the length. Their factory gummy-tips rounds use the shorter brass.

My bolt action 357 will feed the 140 gum tips in 357mag brass. It will not feed the 200+ gr flextips, so I just use 38 spl brass and pay attention to not compress the powder (too much.)
I know that would work, but I would hesitate to do it. If the flex tip will keep someone from accidentally chambering in a 38spl, then ok, otherwise it could be dangerous.
 
Back
Top Bottom