Granted, my data set is limited, but of the few folks I personally know (plus those I've watched their property as I pass by everyday) who've done a timber plan for tax purposes, all them were left with land that was raped and pillaged. In all cases, they can be quoted as saying "geeze, the logging company didn't make it seem so bad--I wouldn't have done it if I knew it would do this."
I'm sure there are some ethical and/or precise loggers out there. I've not yet seen their handywork. And don't get me wrong: would I rather pay XXXX dollars per year to the crown or little to no tithe to the crown per year? That's an easy answer. But if it means jeopardizing the beauty/sanctity of my property, I'd rather pay.