Valkyrie v Grendel

Tim

Checked Out
Staff member
2A Bourbon Hound 2024
2A Bourbon Hound OG
Charter Life Member
Benefactor
Vendor
Multi-Factor Enabled
Joined
Dec 17, 2016
Messages
16,499
Location
A Glass Cage of Emotion
Rating - 100%
85   0   0
I didn’t want to take @11B CIB ’s thread re:Valkyrie reloads on a tangent.

If you were choosing a PRS/DMR competition caliber to reload for, why choose Valkyrie over 6.5 Grendel?

Valkyrie comes out ahead if you just look at wind drift and drop. But Grendel has significantly more energy to ring the gong.
 
Last edited:
What’s the Grendel’s max range? From what I’ve read, the Grendel drops below supersonic speeds a couple hundred yards before the Valkyrie. (1100yds compared to 1300yds, depending on the ammo)

The 224 Valkyrie goes the distance:
vkaUoJ6.jpg


It’s capable of a lot. It’s flatter with less wind drift (ballistics more closely aligned to 6.5CM than 6.5G). It was hyped up initially then scared a lot of people off due to some barrel manufacturers reaming chambers poorly which led to “my Valkyrie sucks” (mainly from bargain brands......CMT, JP, Craddock, and other quality brands were not experiencing these issues).

You don’t need as much barrel length on the Grendel to maximize your performance with it. I’d say it’s also a better choice for hunting larger animals as well (not that the Valk can’t kill predators, but I’m sure this point speaks for itself)

From what I’ve seen, the Grendel is easier to load for (less picky) and there are some fairly inexpensive factory options whereas the Valkyrie doesn’t really dip below 50cpr and that’s with a 75gr TMJ that’s hit or miss (pun intended). The best use for the AE 75gr TMJ’s are either breaking in a barrel and saving the brass OR making “Mexican match” rounds by pulling the 75gr bullet, neck sizing the case again and re-seating a 75gr or 69gr or 77gr TMK. The owner of JP rifles did this very thing and turned 1.5-2MOA ammo into sub MOA performance moving nearly 3100fps for around 80 cents per round all in.

The recoil on the Valkyrie is like a stout 5.56; rapid follow up shots are easy and with timed events, the Valkyrie might provide an advantage.

Another two reasons I personally wanted the Valkyrie was my own suppressor selection. I have a .30 cal can but it’s a beast. With my variety of 5.56 cans, I can run a suppressor that’s at most 75% of the weight down to 37% of the weight of my .30 cal can. I also had a fairly large supply of 77gr Tipped Match King rounds that I wasn’t really using in my 5.56 that would be perfect to use in a Valkyrie

Again, this was a PERSONAL decision for me and my needs.

I feel that now with the bad reamer/bad barrel batches thing out of the way in the 224 Valkyrie world, I’d still opt for a quality barrel/known mfr just to ensure that it’s “right”.
 
@11B CIB , nicely thought out.

I chose Grendel because most of the DMR style matches I've seen in the area keep it under 8oo yards making the extended range of the Valkyrie less of an advantage. I'd rather have the louder, no doubt-about-it, "GOOOOOOONNNNNNNNNNGGGGGGGGGGG" from the couple hundred extra ft/lbs of energy than risk an RO calling hits misses.

If I need to stretch past 7-800, I'll take the 6.5CM bolt gun.
 
Last edited:
@11B CIB , nicely thought out.

I chose Grendel because most of the DMR style matches I've seen in the area keep it under 8oo yards making the extended range of the Valkyrie less of an advantage. I'd rather have the louder, no doubt-about-it, "GOOOOOOONNNNNNNNNNGGGGGGGGGGG" from the couple hundred extra ft/lbs of energy than risk an RO calling hits misses.

If I need to stretch past 7-800, I'll take the 6.5CM bolt gun.

Out at my home range, the 80-90gr ELD/SMK from a Valkyrie hit with much more authority than say a 75-77gr from a 5.56 going 200-400fps slower. I was only using Federal’s Gold Medal 90SMKs at the time, but the 600yd gong at Panteao was unmistakeable compared to my 75gr 5.56.

I’m going to shoot my Valkyrie next weekend so hopefully I don’t embarrass myself. I haven’t been shooting it nearly as long as my other 5.56 rifles, the scope is in MILs (which I’m also not used to). I got 50yd interval dopes from 100 - 600 yds (will run it out to 800yds my next range day as well as conducting a match primer head to head test)
 
Had both. I prefer the Valkyrie.
I broke a couple of extractors in my Grendel. Both during matches unfortunately. Once a VIR and once at the Clinton House.
Valkyrie bolt has more metal in that area and is less prone to failures.
 
Back
Top Bottom