Your opinion?

  • Thread starter JT
  • Start date
  • Replies 21
  • Views 6,626

JT

Chair Wrangler
2A Bourbon Hound 2024
2A Bourbon Hound OG
Benefactor
Vendor
Life Member
Supporting Member
Multi-Factor Enabled
Joined
Mar 4, 2018
Messages
6,026
Location
Wilson NC
Rating - 100%
40   0   0
In true CFF form:

Which costs more? Get that one. ;)
I am assuming the wink was a humorous one. Never let the cost of a chosen firearm be in the running as a deciding factor. ALWAYS in life Try to buy The yardstick. What are all the clones trying to be? Get that. Whether it's a pen to write with or a shirt to wear. always get the best You can afford. You wil find 2 things, first..if you save a little longer you can get the Real one and second..no matter if it pinches your nuts good and hard today, in6 months you won't even remember it.
I have No personal experience with these folks so the answer is I Don't Know. I find that more and more most folks can't muster up a good I Don't Know.
I do know about the guns from the outfit in Alaska. We had one and it Never worked..Never.
Consider the 50 B&M Alaskan if you would like to own The Yardstick.
 
Sorry Ole Pard, I thought you were asking about a Lever gun!!!
Mike spent alot of time and MONEY on getting the 458 and 50 caliber AR platform sorted out. It will make you happy!! I understand the left handed deal, I shoot long guns lefty also.
 
... Mike spent alot of time and MONEY on getting the 458 and 50 caliber AR platform sorted out. It will make you happy!!
It surely would! I'd really love to see that info. Where can I find it?
 
I'm seeking opinions on the Big Horn Armory AR500 in 500 Auto Max -- not so much looking to buy one, just natural curiosity about the rifle and the caliber.


Someone sent me some brass for this a year or so ago. Its just what it says, a rimless 500 S&W. Which is equal to or slightly less capacity than the 50 B&M Super Short, which is a WSM Case cut and trimmed to 1.640 inches.

He is working off the AR 15 action I believe. This is similar to the 458 B&M Super Short AR 15 we built. Olympic Arms at one time, they may still be doing so, were building WSSM Uppers. These were available in all the WSSM calibers, 223, 243 and 25 WSSM. My buddy Sam had one of these, I sent it to Brian at SSK and we built this one on the 458 Super Short. We used the Olympic magazines as I recall. The problem with any semi is that you have to stay within the pressure limits of the gun, which will be around 55000 PSI. The Super Shorts in a bolt gun can push the limits to 65000. 10000 PSI does not sound like much, but in the end it equals 200-300 fps with any given bullet in the 458 SS.

This would be the same in the 50 Super Short as well. I had plans to do a 50 SS, but I was honestly a bit disappointed in the 458 B&M SS in a semi.

Big Horn Armory gun is a full 24 inch barrel. The gun I had built was 16 inches. There would be some difference there, but I would think that 18 inches would be more than enough barrel to burn what powder you could stuff in the .500s.

Before Big Horn sorted out there 500 S&W lever gun, the owner got in touch with me. He really liked the 50 B&M Alaskan and wanted one. Of course he might have been fishing for information too. But we had several conversations and he seemed like a stand up fellow. At this time they were still having issues getting a proper receiver cut for the lever gun. He had Hornady make a run of 400 gr Flat Nose Softs, same as the 500 gr they have, just shorter and come in at 400. Perfect for what he wanted in his lever guns in 500 S&W. He asked if I would like to try a few, and of course I love bullets so I said yes. I was expecting 10-15 bullets to test. A few days went by, and I received the bullets from him and there were over a 100 he had sent. I tested of course and they were good as I expected, and I still have 60-70 of those even today.

Now it does not equal the bigger 50 B&M SA, which is a 2 inch RUM case, but that thing is on a AR 10 with a 18 inch barrel. Its BIG, and its heavy too at 10 lbs.

In my dealings with him, I got the impression he was the real deal, and he would not turn loose of a product until it was good to go! This is why the 500 Lever guns were delayed so long. I would expect the same quality in this AR 500 and concerns.
 
Last edited:
I find that more and more most folks can't muster up a good I Don't Know.
Amen to that!

The only thing I know for sure is that I don't know much. (I do believe that I know how to listen pretty well, though.)
 
Is there information online for these? I have not seen your AR platform designs. I am mightiliy intrigued.

Back in the day I did have them on the B&M Website............ I can look at who, what and where things are being looked at on the backside of the site. When I had those listed, I kept seeing Washington DC and BATF looking at the B&M site. A few times of this, and I said screw this and removed them from the site. Soon they quit looking. And of course I did not have anything for sale anyway.

The AR's are more for SSK to promote. I have three of them, two big AR 10s in .500 and .458, they use a 2 inch RUM cut and trimmed case. I personally like the 458, but mainly because of that wicked 250 CEB Socom Raptor....... In this big AR it runs 2650 fps in the 18 inch barrel. It thrives on either AA 1680 (big muzzle flash) or now, CFE BLK......... a dose of 65/CFE BLK runs at 2650, no muzzle flash. Various 300s to 2400-2450 fps, 325s to 2350 fps, and 350s to 2250 fps and stay under max pressures............

The big 50 B&M SA another AR 10 18 inch gun runs a 335 Raptor to 2325 fps, 350s-380s to 2250-2275 fps and 400s to 2000 fps.

You can see more on this post I did in Big Bores.....................

https://www.carolinafirearmsforum.com/index.php?threads/big-bore-semi-guns.41664/
 
Careful what you ask for^^^^^^^^^^^see above.

Try to stay awake, grown people are talking..............

DSC08573-1.jpg






The 50 B&M Super Short is basically the same as the 500 Big Horn Armory cartridge...........

DSC05602-L.jpg
 
Try to stay awake, grown people are talking..............

DSC08573-1.jpg






The 50 B&M Super Short is basically the same as the 500 Big Horn Armory cartridge...........

DSC05602-L.jpg
If I recall correctly he's showing 2275 out of an 18" barrel with a 400 gr bullet.
 
If I recall correctly he's showing 2275 out of an 18" barrel with a 400 gr bullet.

If he is, he is running 65000+ and that is a lot, more than a semi will hold for very long, unless they pull some sort of magic trick I don't know about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JT
Here's his ballistic comparison chart: I believe in the narrative he said he had worked up and tested loads from 300 to 600 grains.
 

Attachments

  • 500-BHA-comparison-data-04-29-19-with-ballistics-data (1).pdf
    77.3 KB · Views: 2
Last edited:
Here's his ballistic comparison chart: I believe in the narrative he said he had worked up and tested loads from 300 to 600 grains.


I don't think that is real load data? Some sort of Numbers comparison. I would like to see real load data. I did not see any on the site, but I have not went completely through it. We see this sort of thing quite a bit over the years. Recently with the guy that developed the 358 MGP. He knew Sam and I had guns, and Sam told him we were running pressures. He asked us to run his published loads for the cartridge. We loaded, tested, and they were way over pressure, locked our guns up tight, running about 66000 PSI. People get caught up in trying to publish the highest velocity, biggest numbers, and sometimes the pressures catch up at some point. Anyway, lets look for real load data and see what if anything he is publishing?


I found this on Ammo Guide, its listed, but there are no loads listed for it...................

About AmmoGuide Case Diagrams

radio-on.jpg
S.A.E. (in.)
Metric (mm.)
1084.gif

SPECIFICATIONS
Bullet Diameter:

.500 in.
Max Overall Length:
2.250 in.
Case Capacity (est):
64.8 gr. water
Primer Size:
.210 in.

NOMINAL PERFORMANCE
Bullet Weight:

350 gr
Muzzle Velocity:
2,225 fps
Muzzle Energy:
3,849 ft-lbs
1084.gif

1084.gif

"Easy Link" to this cartridge (copy and paste into emails, forums, etc.):
.500 Auto Max - http://ammoguide.com/?catid=1084
If you wanted to produce an AR-platform rifle chambered in .500 S&W Magnum, one obstacle would stubbornly stand in your way - the rimmed case. It would be incompatible with every AR-style magazine designed to date.

The solution? Get rid of it. No, you won't have a .500 S&W Magnum anymore; you'll have a .500 Auto Max, the latest brainchild of Big Horn Armory, noted maker of 19th-century-style lever-action big bores. The way this rimless adaptation of Smith & Wesson's ultra-powerful handgun round can power an AR is the stuff of .50 Beowulf shooters' dreams.

Introduced in 2003, the .500 S&W Magnum brought .308 Winchester-level muzzle energies to the companies largest handgun chassis, producing over 3 times the recoil of the famed .44 Remington Magnum. The .500 Auto Max advances the ballistics of this powerhouse through use of the AR-10 frame and bolt carrier group in their Model AR-500 rifles and pistols.

Ballistics, load data and bullet choices are identical to the .500 S&W Magnum. Also, .500 S&W Magnum shell holder and dies may be used to reload. (The .500 S&W Magnum spec includes a comparatively deep extractor groove so the shell holder operates independantly of the rimmed case design.)

For more information, contact http://www.bighornarmory.com/



And here is the 50 B&M Super Short Listed on Ammo Guide.....


About AmmoGuide Case Diagrams

radio-on.jpg
S.A.E. (in.)
Metric (mm.)
555.gif

SPECIFICATIONS
Bullet Diameter:

.500 in.
Max Overall Length:
2.275 in.
Rifling Twist:
1-in-18.0 in.
Rifling Lands:
6
Case Capacity (est):
68.9 gr. water
Primer Size:
.210 in.

NOMINAL PERFORMANCE
Bullet Weight:

375 gr
Muzzle Velocity:
2,050 fps
Muzzle Energy:
3,501 ft-lbs
555.gif

555.gif

"Easy Link" to this cartridge (copy and paste into emails, forums, etc.):
.50 B&M Super Short - http://ammoguide.com/?catid=555
Parent case for the .50 B&M Super Short is the .300 Winchester Short Magnum, shortened and neck-expanded to .50 caliber.

Developer's rifle is a Winchester M70 Classic WSSM Action with a 16-inch barrel, built by SSK Industries.
----------
 
  • Like
Reactions: JT
Good Morning guys...........

Doing a bit of research this morning, nothing any of you can't do, Just Googgling.......LOL...............One of the first things I ran across is here;

https://www.ballisticmag.com/2020/04/17/big-horn-armory-ar500-auto-max-review/

One of those test review reports........

What I learned, is the rifle is actually a AR 10, and NOT AR 15. I was going on AR 15 because of the magazines and the length of the cartridge in them. It indeed uses AR 15 Magazines. I assume the longer AR 10 magazine might have given issues with the shorter cartridge? That is not my area. Anyway, first photo on this review the rifle looks like some sort of Anti Tank Weapon it is so damn big. Yeah, about like my 50 B&M SA.

Buffalo Bore is doing the loading and factory ammo and using mostly conventional bullets from what I can tell. They don't specify actual bullet. But these numbers fall more in line with what I would expect, they are still pushing it hard however in the attempt to lay claim to "Most Powerful".........Blah blah blah........

This is what is reported........

Load Velocity Avg. Accuracy Best
Buffalo Bore 440gr Hardcast 1,925 2.50 inches 2 inches
Buffalo Bore 350gr JHP 2,235 2.25 inches 1.75 inches
Buffalo Bore 400gr JFN 2,012 3.00 inches 2.33 inches
Steinel 350gr JHP 2,186 2.33 inches 2.25 inches
Steinel 350gr Brass Warhead 2,005 2.66 inches 2.50 inches


The gun used in this report uses a 18 inch barrel, weighs 9.2 lbs, and is 40.25 inches with stock extended. Sometime today I will measure my guns.

My take on the loads.........direct comparison to 50 B&M Super Short.... in a 16 inch bolt gun. Since 500 Auto Max and 50 B&M Super Short are very close to being the same.

440 cast at 1925 fps..................

I have tested 450 North Forks in the 50 SS at 1800 fps 56000 PSI with Lilgun. There is a 425 #13 Copper Solid I have worked with to 1925 fps at 58000 PSI. These are close to the 440 cast in physical size, length. They might be pushing a little here, but not too bad actually.

350 JHP at 2235 fps................

The closest data I have with the 50SS is running a 345 Brass Raptor at 2260 fps for 59000 PSI. Looking at other data, without pressures I have run various 350s to 2200-2250 without concerns. So this is a realistic number, and while slightly over pressure, not by much.

400 JFN 2012 fps........................

With a conventional lead core bullet this is reasonable, and probably at proper pressures. I tested a 405 #13 Solid in 50 SS at 2020 fps at 64000 psi, but this is not a good comparison as this is solid brass, longer bullet, seated deeper and so forth. Other pressure tests with 385 Remingtons showed 2150 fps at 56000 PSI, this being more conventional lead core. So 400 at 2012 fps is very reasonable, and under pressure I would think.

The other 350 JHP at 2186 is zero issues with pressures.

I have not located any real load data yet, I suppose they are keeping that close to hand since it appears Buffalo Bore is doing all the Loading and Factory ammo. In reality in this size case, to reach optimum there is not much of a choice in powders. In all the Super Shorts, it comes down to Lilgun and WW 296. With LilGun winning most of the races with some higher velocity and lower pressures. Other powders are too slow, or two fast.

I will probably look around a little more this morning, but this has pretty much satisfied my curiosity on this.

I still hold that anything that comes from Big Horn is most likely going to be of good quality. About a year ago I thought I might look into one of the lever guns, I did, and prices were reasonable, but I could not justify it with all the B&M 500s laying around......... ???????
 
  • Like
Reactions: JT
Thank you for looking into this. I knew if I asked, I would get a solid answer. I appreciate your digging into this. And the net result is that I am even more impressed with the work done by B&M.
 
Thank you for looking into this. I knew if I asked, I would get a solid answer. I appreciate your digging into this. And the net result is that I am even more impressed with the work done by B&M.


Thanks...........the strong points for B&M is that time has been spent where it counts, BULLETS and Actual, real, Load Data and pressure data. Not Pie in the Sky look at how big my "D@@k it and how fast it can go............ Reason? Most of this has gone to the real world and put to work where it counts. No, not the semi's, those are for play, but the bullets and data are the same, real.

Don't take that wrong, I like Big Horn, but they are in a real business, and it is tough. Hell, I don't see how in the world a small outfit like Big Horn can possibly make a living, shooters, hunters are very tough customers and sales are not in the MILLIONS. Like everything in shooting or hunting, if you are not Hornady, or one of the really big names, it is a tough world. These guys have to cater to "My D##K is bigger and faster", or they can't sell anything. I think Big Horn has a very
good product just based on the contact I had with the owner, and the news I get from folks I know that have had the lever guns. All good. All Positive. But I do get aggravated with some of them with the outlandish claims made about velocity and bullets and crap like that........
 
  • Like
Reactions: JT
Back
Top Bottom