My experience has been both are excellent rifles. I don't have a Model 1 anymore, but still have a Model 2. I like the sights better on the Model 2. If I could have just one, it would be the Model 2.
What year is your model
What year is your model 2? I had a 1977 model 2 briefly, but didn't have the time then to see how accurate it could be. The fit and finish on that one was not nearly as nice as the model 1 I recently bought but as you said, the sights are much better on the model 2's.
Hank
One of the '70sI'll have to look. I agree that fit and finish on later Model 2s isn't as good as Model 1s. I bought three Model 2s back when a distributor had them. One was from the 50s and the other two from the 70s, off the top of my head. I can't remember which one I kept.