CMP Expert Grade M1 Garand

halorocks22

Well-Known Member
Supporting Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2022
Messages
249
Location
High Point
Rating - 100%
14   0   0
I recently purchased an expert grade M1 Garand from the Civilian Marksmanship Program. The whole process from fulfilling the various requirements, to sending in the order form and receiving it at my door took 14 days. The expert-grade rifles are refurbished service-grade rifles with a new stock and a new Criterion-manufactured barrel that gauges 0 at the muzzle and throat. This kills the collector value, but I was looking for a shooter since I insist on shooting every gun in my collection. It was relatively expensive at $1150, but I felt that the premium was worth it to get something guaranteed to be in better condition than a rack-grade rifle and Garands aren't getting any cheaper. Mine is a Springfield-manufacture receiver with a serial number in the low 1,800,000 range that places the date somewhere around July or August of 1943. It is likely that it served in the latter part of WWII and possibly the Korean War as well. It is in generally very good condition, with only the receiver and the underside of the gas tube showing signs of minor pitting/rust. I took it out to the range yesterday and shot it at 50 yards with an average 2-3 MOA group from a seated position using PPU "M1 Garand" .30-06. I'm fairly confident that the limiting factor here is the shooter and that it is capable of better accuracy.

Since I received the rifle, I installed a USGI-spec web sling and got myself 6 additional clips and a bandolier. The en bloc clip system was initially hard to figure out, but became intuitive over time and it's definitely an interesting feeding mechanism. Nothing beats the "ping" the rifle makes when it ejects the en bloc clip after the last round is fired. Recoil is relatively smooth, at least compared to my 1917 Enfield. The sights are fairly simple to use with a large aperture rear window and I only had to adjust the elevation to achieve a traditional battle zero setting of 250 yards. Out of 3 fully-loaded clips fired, I had one failure to feed but that may be due to user error while loading the clips. Overall, the rifle is definitely obsolete by modern standards but it makes an excellent range or hunting gun and I wouldn't feel naked if I had to use this weapon in battle even today.

The M1 Garand has a special sentimental value as I have been obsessed with WWII since I was a kid. I firmly believe that it was the best general-issue infantry weapon of WWII and it laid the foundation for the famous battle rifles of the later periods (FAL, G3, M14, BM59, FN49). It was also the weapon used by the US when they intervened on behalf of South Korea during the Korean War, and that is important to me since I am ethnically Korean and my grandfather participated in that conflict and was likely issued an M1 Garand. Even my father used an M1 Garand for basic training in the Korean Army during the early 1980s. Ammo is expensive at a dollar a pop, but it's worth the price to take it out to the range every now and then and in the meantime appreciate it for its historical value. I highly recommend everyone obtains an M1 Garand from the CMP before the supply dries up completely and you start seeing these going for $3K+. Thanks for reading!

IMG_0082.jpg
 
I can remember the days of the $289 woodless Danish return rifles. Ah, the days of yoreā€¦

There were just over 6million made, so the well will eventually dry up. Get one while you can!

Now to stretch the legs of your rifle and see what she can do!
 
Last edited:
I actually went to CMP in Anniston AL a few weeks back and picked up a service grade M1 (1943, re-barreled in 52). Very nice folks. This is likely not my last purchase with them. I considered an expert but wanted something nostalgic for my first.
 
Last edited:
As for improving accuracy, I'd suggest trying some different ammo. Personally, I found the PPU to be functional, but rather inconsistent and inaccurate in my rifles. I got much better accuracy from Greek (HXP) surplus and handloads. Also, the Creedmoor Sports/Lapua 167 grain match ammo shoots amazing in most of my Garands. YMMV.
 
The creedmoor ammo is good stuff, albeit pricey. Dial the way back machine to the original gold standard of accuracy :cool:
I can't find any of that, and have never shot it. But as for the Creedmoor/Lapua ammo, a few years back, I shot a 5 round, 1 inch group at 200 yards with it out of my H&R service grade Garand. I am now a believer - that stuff is just insanely consistent.
FB_IMG_1685242557306.jpg
 
Oh, I was just musing about the old days when M72 was plentiful. It did shoot well but there are better bullets out there nowadays
 
Last edited:
As for improving accuracy, I'd suggest trying some different ammo. Personally, I found the PPU to be functional, but rather inconsistent and inaccurate in my rifles. I got much better accuracy from Greek (HXP) surplus and handloads. Also, the Creedmoor Sports/Lapua 167 grain match ammo shoots amazing in most of my Garands. YMMV.
fired my old '42 garand using greek ammo at 100yards at a cmp sponsored event. it did really well enough that my spotter thought i was a much better shooter than i am, because i could even call my own misses and where they went.
then i went to anniston and built an expert at their builder class. shot it from the bench and had 10.2, 10.6, 10.0, 10.3, 9.5, 9.9, x.9, 10.7 using creedmore.
the gun might be technologically outdated... but it's still the greatest battle implement. and m2ap will still hurt an engine pretty bad. of course, you'd need m2ap and who has a few clips of that loaded up and sitting next to their safe? that's just crazy.
 
fired my old '42 garand using greek ammo at 100yards at a cmp sponsored event. it did really well enough that my spotter thought i was a much better shooter than i am, because i could even call my own misses and where they went.
then i went to anniston and built an expert at their builder class. shot it from the bench and had 10.2, 10.6, 10.0, 10.3, 9.5, 9.9, x.9, 10.7 using creedmore.
the gun might be technologically outdated... but it's still the greatest battle implement. and m2ap will still hurt an engine pretty bad. of course, you'd need m2ap and who has a few clips of that loaded up and sitting next to their safe? that's just crazy.
Smirk. Right. Just crazy.

M2ap.... redefining the definition of cover and concealment since the 40's.
 
I remember seeing M1s from the CMP for around $300 for rack grades... and I am sure other members remember better prices from better days. Awesome that you picked up such a great piece, mine is an expert as well. I would rather have a functional, usable example of the operating system/platform than a perfect replica or collector's piece that can't be used. The ping is just... as American as apple pie. It makes me smile. Its that warm fuzzy feeling, like shooting ammo you don't have to pay for, shooting a cannon for the first time, or just hearing the echoes reverberate off the mountains as you slam in another clip without getting Garand thumb.

I am toying with the idea of getting on the list for the 1911s... but from what I understand, they are rough but likely not good shooters
 
I remember seeing M1s from the CMP for around $300 for rack grades... and I am sure other members remember better prices from better days. Awesome that you picked up such a great piece, mine is an expert as well. I would rather have a functional, usable example of the operating system/platform than a perfect replica or collector's piece that can't be used. The ping is just... as American as apple pie. It makes me smile. Its that warm fuzzy feeling, like shooting ammo you don't have to pay for, shooting a cannon for the first time, or just hearing the echoes reverberate off the mountains as you slam in another clip without getting Garand thumb.

I am toying with the idea of getting on the list for the 1911s... but from what I understand, they are rough but likely not good shooters

Better days indeed!! I wish I had been old enough to buy guns back in the day when the land flowed with military surplus rifles like milk and honey. That and Apple stocks/Bitcoin šŸ¤£.

The CMP 1911's sure do look neat, but there are so many decent and cheap 1911's on the market nowadays I'd only get one from the CMP for collection purposes only. Tisas makes a high-quality and pretty faithful recreation of a WWII-era 1911 service pistol for under $400.
 
I am toying with the idea of getting on the list for the 1911s... but from what I understand, they are rough but likely not good shooters
The main issue is more just the simple price vs. quality analysis. They are not as rough as I expected. But they are also not cheap through CMP by any stretch. I rolled the dice and got a very nice field grade Remington Rand with matching slide and frame (and other parts). It is an excellent shooter as well, and I am very satisfied with what I got. But some folks get obvious mismatches/mixmasters or worse, the dreaded "replacement" slide. I cannot say I would've been happy or satisfied if I'd got a replacement slide for what I paid for mine. But I got lucky. Regardless, you'll probably get a good shooter, but if you are not as lucky, you might overpay a good bit for what you get.

FB_IMG_1685589950516.jpg
 
Back
Top Bottom