Having owned metric cruisers, sport bikes, dirt bikes, and Harleys, I will never ride anything but a Harley again. With Indian being owned by Polaris, I'll never go near them- ever. Every Polaris I've come across was accompanied by some looking problem. I have heard they made some changes in their QC but when it comes down to the idea of trusting my life to them, after the issues I've had with them... I'll stick to H-D.
To me, Polaris is a lot like Taurus. They can make a pretty pistol, but there's no way in hell I'll trust my life to it.
tl:dr
Road King with quick detachable batwing fairing. That leaves you the option to have your radio and shield, just a clear shield, or nothing at all blocking the wind. It's the most versatile option.