Well, now I want a 1911 .45!

Millie

Millie

Get on with your life!!!
Supporting Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2017
Messages
11,579
Location
NC
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
My life just got more complicated today. I got to shoot the Sig p365, and didn't much like it. I was surprised! So that idea is over.
So then I got to shoot a .45 again and loved it! It's huge and heavy (felt like 7 pounds) and has a light on it and it's some type of a 1911, I'm pretty sure. This would not be a concealable gun for anyone, I'm thinking, but it was fun to shoot. So now I want one of those.....(sigh.)
Now we have to do this "search out/shoot lots of them" all over again with .45s.....lol.
Let me hear your thoughts on this. (This would be a gun for the house/range/fun, not to carry, as I need it to be big and heavy so it's pushy and not snappy.)
 
Millie said:
My life just got more complicated today. I got to shoot the Sig p365, and didn't much like it. I was surprised! So that idea is over.
So then I got to shoot a .45 again and loved it! It's huge and heavy (felt like 7 pounds) and has a light on it and it's some type of a 1911, I'm pretty sure. This would not be a concealable gun for anyone, I'm thinking, but it was fun to shoot. So now I want one of those.....(sigh.)
Now we have to do this "search out/shoot lots of them" all over again with .45s.....lol.
Let me hear your thoughts on this. (This would be a gun for the house/range/fun, not to carry, as I need it to be big and heavy so it's pushy and not snappy.)
Click to expand...

Just try a Commander (4.25") and Gov't (5") in a steel frame and see which one balances and feels better to you. Pretty much all 1911 frames are about the same. Pick your size and then it just comes down to how much you want to spend. An average 1911 trigger is pretty good and they are fun to shoot. But beware, it is a deep dark hole. Lots of options and $$$. Plus maybe find someone close by and go through the break down and cleaning. It is a little more complicated than some other guns. Make sure you are able to maintain it and keep it going. Lots of smart 1911 people on this site so you'll have plenty of guidance.
 
Yessss. I say again. One of us. One of us. One of us......

Just like your revolver thread. All metal guns dampen recoil dramatically. Making them much more comfortable (read fun) to shoot alot.

That same weight makes them hard to carry/conceal. Hence the whole spectrum of firearms.

If it was simple. Every single owner would buy one single firearm for all things. But physics are real lol. Hence the choices and decisions we all make.

Welcome to the rabbit hole:cool::p:D
 
Welcome to the 1911 side.

You can spend from $300 to 5000 + on 1911s.
Start looking at the BST here on CFF and I'm sure you will find a good one for your needs.
 
If I have to shoot a 1911 I prefer 9mm 1911s. They are less pushy and less snappy than .45s but more importantly cheaper to shoot and they hold more rounds. 9mm 1911 is also more "fun" in my opinion.

I just got one of the newer Colt series 70 competition models (and have other 1911s) and it has been flawless...I'd recommend that.
 
I told you when you first started do not listen to those who say a female can’t shot any firearm ... with proper training and confidence. “A .45 is toooo much gun for a woman” is BS male stupidity ... and you proved that idea was wrong today GOOD FOR YOU! As to weight more like 3lbs loaded and that along with the slower huge chunk of lead exiting it means the “push” you mention is the result rather than the “snap”. The 1911 platform is a little different than others with its trigger design and actual mechanics to fire (grip safety, thumb safety and trigger manipulation) so it does take a little practice to be smooth and correct if called upon so you and it flow as one in a natural way. Now that natural way though has been compared to a Jedi and his light saber ... elegant and deadly! Also 1911’s to me are kinda like vintage cars ... they need a little more attention and love to run while Glocks and such are Honda Civics ... they run damn reliable and economically with about anyone. 1911’s aren’t that complicated but they just need a little more love ... my carry gun (a 1911 hybrid SA EMP) gets loved every Sunday with a basic breaking down, cleaning and oiling. My Glocks ... I have hanging around maybe once a year?

Millie, do not buy a 1911 ... not yet. Once you go down that road you’ll never look at other handguns quite the same ... and they multiply quicker in my safe than all other types of firearms combined. But when you do buy that first one you’ll look at all your other semiautos a little different.
 
I remember when I crossed that 1911 bridge. Now I have 4 of them, all government models. May add a commander one day and also a 9mm version. 45acp is my favorite round to shoot so a 1911 for me is a great day at the range.



Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
NCFubar said:
I told you when you first started do not listen to those who say a female can’t shot any firearm ... with proper training and confidence. “A .45 is toooo much gun for a woman” is BS male stupidity ... and you proved that idea was wrong today GOOD FOR YOU! As to weight more like 3lbs loaded and that along with the slower huge chunk of lead exiting it means the “push” you mention is the result rather than the “snap”. The 1911 platform is a little different than others with its trigger design and actual mechanics to fire (grip safety, thumb safety and trigger manipulation) so it does take a little practice to be smooth and correct if called upon so you and it flow as one in a natural way. Now that natural way though has been compared to a Jedi and his light saber ... elegant and deadly! Also 1911’s to me are kinda like vintage cars ... they need a little more attention and love to run while Glocks and such are Honda Civics ... they run damn reliable and economically with about anyone. 1911’s aren’t that complicated but they just need a little more love ... my carry gun (a 1911 hybrid SA EMP) gets loved every Sunday with a basic breaking down, cleaning and oiling. My Glocks ... I have hanging around maybe once a year?

Millie, do not buy a 1911 ... not yet. Once you go down that road you’ll never look at other handguns quite the same ... and they multiply quicker in my safe than all other types of firearms combined. But when you do buy that first one you’ll look at all your other semiautos a little different.
Click to expand...
Why not buy one soon-ish? Isn't my p238 sort of modeled on a 1911? I'm used to the safety and all the parts.....and I didn't like the Sig 9mm, so that's out!
 
CZfool68 said:
Just try a Commander (4.25") and Gov't (5") in a steel frame and see which one balances and feels better to you. Pretty much all 1911 frames are about the same. Pick your size and then it just comes down to how much you want to spend. An average 1911 trigger is pretty good and they are fun to shoot. But beware, it is a deep dark hole. Lots of options and $$$. Plus maybe find someone close by and go through the break down and cleaning. It is a little more complicated than some other guns. Make sure you are able to maintain it and keep it going. Lots of smart 1911 people on this site so you'll have plenty of guidance.
Click to expand...
Maintenance: I'll try to get Tony, my coach, to do his for me if we have time next lesson! I've learned how to do the p238 pretty well, and I'm pretty a determined person.
 
ronn47 said:
Welcome to the 1911 side.

You can spend from $300 to 5000 + on 1911s.
Start looking at the BST here on CFF and I'm sure you will find a good one for your needs.
Click to expand...

$5K? You must be going to the bargain bin; have seen some going for more than #10K o_O
 
Last edited:
Millie said:
Maintenance: I'll try to get Tony, my coach, to do his for me if we have time next lesson! I've learned how to do the p238 pretty well, and I'm pretty a determined person.
Click to expand...
Here is a video that shows the full, detailed disassembly of a 1911. The first 20 seconds of the video is a field strip - everything else is the detailed disassembly and reassembly. Oh, and everything is done without any tools!

 
Last edited:
I love shooting big, slow .45's. The 1911 platform is my favorite. And no, I won't be carrying any configuration of .45. Too big and too heavy.

That said, for steel challenge, this is my baby because I can see my hits on target. I am an oldster.
 
gc70 said:
Here is a video that shows the full, detailed disassembly of a 1911. The first 20 seconds of the video is a field strip - everything else is the detailed disassembly and reassembly. Oh, and everything is done without any tools!

Click to expand...

That's a lotta parts!! But you learn how, I guess, if you have to....
 
Millie said:
Why not buy one soon-ish? Isn't my p238 sort of modeled on a 1911? I'm used to the safety and all the parts.....and I didn't like the Sig 9mm, so that's out!
Click to expand...

I was joking about buying one soon ... you’ll get spoiled and run for more ... 1911’s must be coated in crack because to many they can be addicty.

I forgot you had the P238 ... and yeah it’s a cousin to the 1911 sorta but not the same. The actual manipulation and utilization of the thumb safety may seem similar between the two but when you really start to drive a 1911 like it can run you’ll see the difference. The trigger might seem the same but when you look I said it is totally different and the 1911’s is like a fine Swiss watch with its feel and some of us become almost hooked on it.

When you do buy a 1911 just do like any other purchase ... don’t rush and do all your reasearch. People will give you a bunch of different suggestions and their opinions but those do come in different price ranges so have your budget planned out and what you actually want to spend for what you get. As I said 1911’s do take more owner interaction from maintenance to even possible troubleshooting sometimes ... a friend or shooting coach is nice here and the forum can also shed light on things but sometimes hands on showing is needed more than even YouTube.
 
I have 1911’s in .45acp, .38super and 9mm, and in full and commander sizes, they are all great to shoot.

Some dislike the external safety, some dislike the grip safety, and one real piece of work says that it’s a poor choice for a combat handgun because you might accidentally push the slide stop out. None of that stuff bothers me.

As you’ve heard 1,000 times, go shoot them and see how they feel.
 
Millie, what need are you trying to fill? 1911 are great. I love them. I've heard more that one woman like the .45ACP because, as you mentioned it's more of a push than a snap. Gun weight has a lot to do with it and the .45ACP is a lower pressure round. But, the form factor and weight preclude carry for many. (Not all. ;)) Is this to be a house gun?
Go ahead and shoot other guns as well, including 9mm Glocks, S&W, etc. You might find one of the sub-compact 9mm's to be a good balance of size an shootability. The synthetic frame of many of modern 9mm's absorb some shock. For a house gun, there is a specific reason I like the Glocks, 33rd magazines.
 
Have gun-will travel said:
Millie find out what the pistol you shot was ,brand,barrel length and sights. Then ask to shoot it again. If you still like it look for one just like it.
Click to expand...
I'm taking notes next time and will post the info. I have a feeling this is one of those super-pricey ones, though. Lol.
But I'll find out and see if I can try it out again. Shall I get him some ammo for letting me try his gun out... yet again? (Is that the polite thing to do?)
 
georgel said:
Millie, what need are you trying to fill? 1911 are great. I love them. I've heard more that one woman like the .45ACP because, as you mentioned it's more of a push than a snap. Gun weight has a lot to do with it and the .45ACP is a lower pressure round. But, the form factor and weight preclude carry for many. (Not all. ;)) Is this to be a house gun?
Go ahead and shoot other guns as well, including 9mm Glocks, S&W, etc. You might find one of the sub-compact 9mm's to be a good balance of size an shootability. The synthetic frame of many of modern 9mm's absorb some shock. For a house gun, there is a specific reason I like the Glocks, 33rd magazines.
Click to expand...
This will be a house gun. And it will visit the range.
As for Glocks, I've tried 9mm, .380, and maybe more, it's been a lot. They were painful. I shot a Shield, not bad, but not as good as the .45. I tried lots of guns in 9mm. I've also sadly let the idea of the p365 go, it was not fun to shoot....dream killer! Lol.
I'm all set in the carry gun department, at least for the foreseeable future...
 
JimB said:
I have 1911’s in .45acp, .38super and 9mm, and in full and commander sizes, they are all great to shoot.

Some dislike the external safety, some dislike the grip safety, and one real piece of work says that it’s a poor choice for a combat handgun because you might accidentally push the slide stop out. None of that stuff bothers me.

As you’ve heard 1,000 times, go shoot them and see how they feel.
Click to expand...
Yes, I'll be trying to shoot a bunch of them. The research is half the fun!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom