EDC pocket knife suggestions

Engineerguy30

Active Member
Joined
Jan 28, 2022
Messages
63
Location
Huntersville, NC
Rating - 100%
5   0   0
Hello all,

I am looking for suggestions on a pocket knife for everyday use.

Background...

I am a mechanical engineer, and am very hands on. ThIs would be used for stripping wire, opening boxes, and light industrial applications.

I DO NOT like multi tools

I currently use a tanto style knife but it is a cheap knife that doesn't hold an edge.

Let me know what your suggestion would be
 
Benchmade?
Leatherman knife?
One is cheaper than the other, obviously, but both are solid that I really enjoy
 
My dad is hell on pocket knives. He brings them to me several at a time to sharpen and fix. I bought him a couple Kershaw folders and he don't bring them to me half as often as he did before. For the money Kershaw imo is hard to beat for a everyday pocket knife
 
Given that you said it’ll be a user and not a pocket queen, it may have a higher chance of being lost or broken. I’d stay away from expensive.

Sharpness will be key, so crap steel will be frustrating. You’ll get an edge on it but it won’t keep.

Something in the $50 range would be totally functional for you. As mentioned, the Spyderco Tenacious fits this bill.

I have the Spyderco sharpening set and it works great—better than most of the gimmicky sharpening gizmos.

This is my daily office carry:
Spyderco Tenacious Folding Utility Pocket Knife with 3.39" Black Stainless Steel Blade and Durable G-10 Handle - Everyday Carry - PlainEdge - C122GBBKP https://a.co/d/9PjJDlq

Had it for 10+ years and it only gets better with age. The black color helps it not jump right out (like chrome or other color will).
 
Last edited:
For stripping wire and light industrial you’re going to want something sturdy with a strong “back” imo .I am hard on knives and im going to give another vote to spyderco. Ive been carrying this one thats called a “chinese lum” for a while now and i can tell you its strong. I have used this blade in ways it shouldn’t be ,like prying and such but it hangs right in there!

IMG_0823.jpeg
 
I would not invest in a very expensive pocket knife in your line of work. Below is a Klein pocket knife made for electricians that costs $15 from Home Depot or Lowes. I've broken some nice pocket knives when I worked in construction. I quickly learned to get the cheaper stuff for work and save the high-end stuff for carrying the rest of the time.

Edited to add: At $15 buy 3 or 4 of them and keep some in your vehicle. So if one gets dull grab another and sharpen later, or if one breaks, grab another one. Save you some down time.

 
Last edited:
My dad is hell on pocket knives. He brings them to me several at a time to sharpen and fix. I bought him a couple Kershaw folders and he don't bring them to me half as often as he did before. For the money Kershaw imo is hard to beat for a everyday pocket knife
Here’s a deal on a Kershaw. Buy 5 of ‘em and stick the other 4 in a drawer. I bought two of these for Christmas gifts, and after my son opened his…I ordered one for myself.


They have four models on clearance, including two more at $20/ea:

 
As I have said on other threads (or I would tell you in a conversation in person) I've carried everything from Kershaw to Microtech, from manual, to assisted, to auto and out the front knives, and I have ended up back at manual opening Spydercos. I'm kind of done with liner locks, although Spyderco does them well (as in the aforementioned Tenacious). I like lock backs better than anything else but have a few with "compression locks". I'm not on fire about them like some are but they are okay. I would humbly suggest a strong locking folder of some sort.

The Buck 110 is THE American standard, but the traditional model is HEAVY-there are lighter options available:

The cheapest "best" knife out there, period:
(In spite of "MSRP" I've seen these as cheap as $21-ish...)

Most Cold Steel folders are good choices-just don't go too cheap or too big for practical carry-although I know a guy that carries TWO Large Voyagers EDC...:eek:

Spyderco is WELL thought of-by me and others:

Benchmade is also pretty good and very costly as well:
 
It would be good to know what you’re looking or willing to spend. A Benchmade 940, Spyderco Tenacious, or something like a CR Sebenza on the higher end would work great but something from Gerber, Kershaw, or CRKT would work just fine as well. I prefer various designs from CRKT for a ”budget” knife but its just personal preference.
 
Amazon product ASIN B003Z77ZP8
SOG Kilowatt.
Has built in Cable stripper, UTP stripper, Gauge stripper.
3.4" blade, so not to short, not too long.
AUS-8, so slightly lower quality steel than VG-10, but still pretty good, and keeps the price down.
57-58 rockwell, so holds and edge well, but not as chippy as harder blades.
Plain edge, so easier to resharpen.
Nylon handle not conductive.
 
Last edited:
I am a mechanical engineer, and am very hands on. ThIs would be used for stripping wire, opening boxes, and light industrial applications.

Let me know what your suggestion would be

That’s the case, I’d probably just carry a retractable utility knife.

But for what you’re wanting, a decent pocket knife would work, as well. I have an old Buck 703 my Dad gave me when I was a youngin and still carry it just about every day.

IMG_4991.jpeg
 
Last edited:
May or may not work for what you are doing but the Boker Kalishnikov auto knives are my daily carry. But I am cheez wiz kinda guy living in a Swiss cheese world.
 
Last edited:
Another +1 for Kershaw. I’ve been carrying Blurs for around 10yr. I have a handful of them now and love that they’re a solid feeling knife, hold a decent edge, and are cheap enough ($50-75) that if I lose it I won’t be upset.

It also helps that Kershaw has a great warranty. The torsion bar, which assists opening, broke on one of my oldest ones. I went to their site, filled out the warranty form, they sent me the part, along with a few spares as I requested, in about a week. They also offer free lifetime sharpening. I can’t ask for much more than that.
 
Get a Benchmade folder with the axis lock that is manual and ambidextrous. Check out the 940 models.
The axis lock is much easier and faster to open and close the blade one handed than it is with a liner lock, frame lock, or auto.
 
I've collected lots of medium-priced, EDC knives over the years. Since the early 90's, I've rotated lots, but I keep going back to the Spyderco Delica series as my #1.

1704124252487.png
 
I carry a Marine Corps type knife that has a few tools such as punch,,knife, screwdriver,can opener which folds into a neat closed position no bigger than most pocket knives. The originals are usually hard to find and pricey but Marbles makes a pretty nice one that costs less than 20 bucks.
Do a search on Marbles 390 Outdoor Knife if interested.
 
Civil/Geotech eng. here, I really dig the Kershaw Cryo/Cryo2 as a general use knife.

Really robust and thick blade that still holds an edge pretty well, great for all manner of prying/digging as well as cutting.

 
I favor cleaver style blades. Pocket clip, right rear pocket. It's a tool and that's what my knife has to do. I just don't have any use for pocket knives with pointy blades that are made for stabbing.

Top to bottom
1) Klein tools. This is my standard everyday work knife. Made in Japan, it holds an edge very well and is built tight.
2) Gerber Quadrant G-10. My dress-up/impress the ladies knife. 😐
3) Gerber Flatiron. My around the outside/woods knife.
IMG_0817 - Copy.JPG

The flatiron is a freakin ax. The blade is thick and tough. This is the largest knife I'll pocket carry.
The Quadrant is nicely balanced and small enough to not look stupid in nice jeans or slacks. The design mimics an old straight blade razor. It's very light. This would be a great edc knife too.
The Klein is perfect for all day at work. It's tough but small.
All of these knives are thin. The handles are just wide enough to hold the blade. That's the most important feature in a pocket knife for me. Some of these clip knives out there are absurd. Handles as thick as my G41.

@Engineerguy30 all of these are great for boxes, a regular task for the Klein. Far less likely to slice what's inside. And excellent at stripping wire, the cleaver blade is well suited for that. I only use them for large wire though, #8awg and larger. 4/0 to 500 mcm is where they really shine. Anything smaller than #8 and I just use the wire strippers.
I used to favor the Tanto style like you, but I've found the cleaver to be even better for real-world stuff. I think they're safer to use also.

Lastly, these guys that can afford to lose or break a $300 benchmade, more power to them. Cause that's what's gonna happen when you work for a living. That's my 4th Klein knife, the other 3 I lost on the job.
 
I'm gonna give several recommendations at different price points from most to least expensive.

1) Spyderco PM3 in either S45VN or S30V
2) Kershaw Blur in S30V
3) Spyderco Delica in VG-10
4) Ontario RATII in D2
5) Eafengrow EF223 in D2

You have a range of options there from the $140-150 to the $20 range.

I own and have used them all. I will say the RAT II is a recent acquisition but I like it.
 
I'm gonna give several recommendations at different price points from most to least expensive.

1) Spyderco PM3 in either S45VN or S30V
2) Kershaw Blur in S30V
3) Spyderco Delica in VG-10
4) Ontario RATII in D2
5) Eafengrow EF223 in D2

This list is worth quoting.

I like the RATs in D2 because I have a tendency to lose pocket knives.
 
Amazon product ASIN B003Z77ZP8
SOG Kilowatt.
Has built in Cable stripper, UTP stripper, Gauge stripper.
3.4" blade, so not to short, not too long.
AUS-8, so slightly lower quality steel than VG-10, but still pretty good, and keeps the price down.
57-58 rockwell, so holds and edge well, but not as chippy as harder blades.
Plain edge, so easier to resharpen.
Nylon handle not conductive.
That's impressive. I've a Cold Steel 4" Tanto Voyager I've been carrying for over a decade daily that's AUS 8A steel. It's easy to sharpen to shave with, and holds an edge. That SOG looks like it's exactly what he's looking for.
 
Buy the Eafengrow......
I’ve carried one of my two every day for the last two years. Right up until I broke a clip ~2 weeks ago. Can’t get them to respond to IG DM or email, and can’t find a replacement on my own. ☹️

Other than that, I like everything about those knives.
 
I’ve carried one of my two every day for the last two years. Right up until I broke a clip ~2 weeks ago. Can’t get them to respond to IG DM or email, and can’t find a replacement on my own. ☹️

Other than that, I like everything about those knives.
I had two, just gave the orange one to my youngest son. I kept the black one. I gave another black one to my oldest son several years ago. They are very good knives for the price point.
 
Last edited:
The one knife I have but don't use (yet) is a Case, because it was given to me as a graduation gift from grad school and has my name and credentials engraved on the blade.

Otherwise I use a Benchmade North Fork, a Kershaw Cryo, and a Gerber Paraframe. I also have a CRKT M1-03K which is fair, and just doesn't get a lot of use. I use the Kershaw, a lot.
 
I favor cleaver style blades. Pocket clip, right rear pocket. It's a tool and that's what my knife has to do. I just don't have any use for pocket knives with pointy blades that are made for stabbing.

Top to bottom
1) Klein tools. This is my standard everyday work knife. Made in Japan, it holds an edge very well and is built tight.
2) Gerber Quadrant G-10. My dress-up/impress the ladies knife. 😐
3) Gerber Flatiron. My around the outside/woods knife.
View attachment 720946

The flatiron is a freakin ax. The blade is thick and tough. This is the largest knife I'll pocket carry.
The Quadrant is nicely balanced and small enough to not look stupid in nice jeans or slacks. The design mimics an old straight blade razor. It's very light. This would be a great edc knife too.
The Klein is perfect for all day at work. It's tough but small.
All of these knives are thin. The handles are just wide enough to hold the blade. That's the most important feature in a pocket knife for me. Some of these clip knives out there are absurd. Handles as thick as my G41.

@Engineerguy30 all of these are great for boxes, a regular task for the Klein. Far less likely to slice what's inside. And excellent at stripping wire, the cleaver blade is well suited for that. I only use them for large wire though, #8awg and larger. 4/0 to 500 mcm is where they really shine. Anything smaller than #8 and I just use the wire strippers.
I used to favor the Tanto style like you, but I've found the cleaver to be even better for real-world stuff. I think they're safer to use also.

Lastly, these guys that can afford to lose or break a $300 benchmade, more power to them. Cause that's what's gonna happen when you work for a living. That's my 4th Klein knife, the other 3 I lost on the job.
I bought the Klein knife a couple years ago. It’s still in the package in a tool box for electrical panel changeouts which I haven’t done one in quite a while. I need to get it out because a pointy blade is a couple stitches waiting to happen. For romex I have a little slitter that attaches to a set of strippers. But for receptacle boxes it will not go deep enough. The Klein allows one to place the thumb in front of the blade.
 
I have a few Benchmades, and they're outstanding knives. But my EDC is a CRKT Steigerwalt assisted opener. It's beat to hell, and the Veff serrations are worn from my occasional improper sharpening - but it's reliable with a solid lockup. I like the Ignitor action as well. For less than $50, and going on 5 years of hard use, it owes me nothing.
 
I would not invest in a very expensive pocket knife in your line of work. Below is a Klein pocket knife made for electricians that costs $15 from Home Depot or Lowes. I've broken some nice pocket knives when I worked in construction. I quickly learned to get the cheaper stuff for work and save the high-end stuff for carrying the rest of the time.

Edited to add: At $15 buy 3 or 4 of them and keep some in your vehicle. So if one gets dull grab another and sharpen later, or if one breaks, grab another one. Save you some down time.


Another +1 for Kershaw. I’ve been carrying Blurs for around 10yr. I have a handful of them now and love that they’re a solid feeling knife, hold a decent edge, and are cheap enough ($50-75) that if I lose it I won’t be upset.

It also helps that Kershaw has a great warranty. The torsion bar, which assists opening, broke on one of my oldest ones. I went to their site, filled out the warranty form, they sent me the part, along with a few spares as I requested, in about a week. They also offer free lifetime sharpening. I can’t ask for much more than that.

I like the Kershaw Blur as an EDC knife that gets used and abused. Not sure I'd treat a more expensive knife the same way which defeats the purpose of carrying it for me. Mine has has the s30v blade material.
As an admitted Blur fan, I have carried the Klien for a couple of months as a work knife and have been pleasantly surprised. The knife came "free" when I bought a Klien work backpack.

I work in Industrial maintenance and use my pocket knife daily, A LOT...and the Klien has held up well. I finally had to put it on the Worksharp yesterday but considering how much I use it, the factree edge held up well.20231002_203303.jpg
20231002_203228.jpg
The Klien has built in wire stripping reliefs but I'd just assume walk to my box and grab a pair of strippers.
 
Back
Top Bottom